Visble.ai vs. Otterly.ai: A Comparative Analysis
SERP ranks are now obsolete. The user journey now begins with a synthesised answer from an AI, be it Google's AI Overviews, ChatGPT, Gemini, or Perplexity.
This shift has created Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO). It’s a new discipline that’s important for marketing, content, and PR teams.
If an AI search engine is the first touchpoint, and your brand isn't being cited in the answer, you are invisible to a massive, fast-growing segment of the market. Your traditional SEO toolkit is blind to this reality.
Here’s a definitive comparison to provide the expert insight necessary to choose the right command centre for your brand's AI future.
Key Takeaways
- The SEO to GEO Shift: The user journey has fundamentally changed from optimising for link rank (SEO) to optimising for brand citation (GEO) within AI-generated responses.
- Two Pillars of GEO: AI visibility is determined by two factors: Discovery (brand mentions/sentiment in high-trust, third-party content) and topical authority (structured, cite-ready on-site data).
- Otterly.ai is for Monitoring and Technical Fixes: Otterly.ai is an observational tool best suited for prompt monitoring, daily tracking, and technical web audits (AI readiness). Its prompt allowance is a key limitation for large scale analysis of your industry.
- Visble.ai is for Strategic Control and Optimisation: Visble.ai is built for proactive, goal oriented GEO. It provides strategic control through campaign-based prompt generation, deeper source/trend analysis, and a superior entry-level prompt volume for competitive experimentation.
- The Buying Decision: Choose Visble.ai for strategic, competitive intelligence and narrative control. Go with Otterly for fast, basic monitoring and immediate technical compliance/audit needs.
The Foundational Challenge: From Ranking to Citing
The core difference between SEO and GEO is the shift from a “ranking” problem to “being cited” problem. AI models rely on two key pillars to determine your visibility:
- Discovery (The Narrative): How frequently and positively your brand is mentioned across high-trust, third-party content (e.g., industry news, Reddit, forums).
- Topical Authority (The semantics): The accessibility and structured format of your on-site content, making it safe for the LLM to pull facts and data points.
The platform you choose must provide clear paths to address both.
| Key Visibility Signal | Traditional SEO Focus | Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) |
|---|---|---|
| User Query | Short-tail keywords (e.g., "best CRM") | Conversational Prompts (e.g., "What are the three best CRM solutions for a team of ten?") |
| Success Metric | Click-Through-Rate (CTR) from a #1 link | Brand Citation Frequency and Sentiment within the AI Answer |
| Content Strategy | Blogs, guides with keywords | Structured data, tables, definitional content, and FAQs |
What is Otterly.ai
Otterly.ai is an AI search monitoring platform. It’s focused on Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) and brand safety. You can track your brand mentions, sentiment, and website citations across leading AI search engines like ChatGPT, Google AI Overviews, and Perplexity on a single prompt level.
It is an observational data-gathering tool. A tool that helps you analyse how your brand appears. But there are limited actionable steps beyond that. It's like you get the data and analysis, but the strategic moves to improve are limited in otterly.ai.
The platform guides users on exactly what and where to publish to improve brand positioning in AI-generated responses.
Head-to-Head Feature Comparison: The Expert Matrix
To assess which tool is the right fit, let’s analyse the functional depth of their core features, particularly their approach to analytics, control, and implementation.
| Feature Category | Visble.ai | Otterly.ai | Strategic Implication |
|---|---|---|---|
| Analysis Granularity | Both Aggregated and Individual prompt-level analysis provided. | Only prompt-level analysis is provided. | Visble.ai enables macro-trend spotting (Aggregated) while maintaining individual detail. Otterly.ai is limited to a single, specific prompt result. |
| Campaign Control | Campaigns divided according to objective. Prompts are generated as per the objective, granting user control. | Campaigns are created on random prompts; the user lacks control over the prompt choice. | A major differentiator. Visble.ai allows alignment with business goals (e.g., "Targeting Mid-Market Segment"), offering genuine strategic GEO execution. |
| Source & Trend Analysis | Detailed source analysis with historical trends is provided. | Tracks AI-generated source citations and trends. | The core of Authority. Visble.ai pinpoints which external domains are influencing the AI's opinion of your brand, directing your brand mention, UGC and competitive analysis strategy. |
| Content Deep Dive | Detailed response and topic analysis are provided. | No content analysis is provided. | Narrative Control. Visble.ai shows which claims or specific topics from your website were pulled by the LLM, allowing you to refine your on-page messaging for maximum citation. |
| Web Audit Function | Does not provide web audits. | Provides Web Audit (focused on AI readiness). | Otterly’s implementation strength. It directly addresses technical GEO readiness, bridging the gap between insight and the actions developers or SEOs need to take on-site. |
| Reporting Frequency | Weekly analysis update (customizable for enterprise). | Daily analysis update provided. | Otterly.ai provides faster feedback loops, critical in volatile search spaces. Visble.ai's weekly focus is more suited for high-level strategy and trend identification. |
| Entry-Level Value | Starter Plan: $29/month for 50 prompts, allowing two campaigns. Business plan: $249/month with 1500 prompts and unlimited campaigns. Enterprise Plan: Custom Pricing | Started Plan: $29/month for 15 prompts. Standard Plan: $189/month for 100 prompts. Premium Plan: $489/month for 400 prompts. | Visble.ai is the clear winner on volume. It provides comparatively more prompt tracking for the same price, essential for competitive and bulk experimentation. |
What AI Visibility Tool Features Matter for Your Brand
1. Prompt Control & Objective-Based GEO
The largest gap is in Campaign Control.
- Visble.ai provides you with a platform where prompts are generated according to the campaign objective. It helps you move from passive monitoring to proactive market shaping.
You don't just track if you're mentioned. You’ll also know if you're mentioned favourably when a user asks a comparison question relevant to your target persona.
- Otterly.ai’s approach is limited to a random set of prompts with no user control. It severely restricts strategic use. With GEO, if you can’t control the conversation you’re monitoring, you can't align the data with your marketing P&L. So, you lack full control of competitive analysis and product launch tracking.
2. Source and Response Analysis
AI models are trained to synthesise and narrate. They first validate information, then cite it.
- Visble.ai’s Source & Trend Analysis outperforms Otterly.ai here. It doesn't just show where your brand was mentioned; it tracks the trend of that source's influence on the LLM.
- The Detailed Response and Topic Analysis provides narrative control. It breaks down the AI’s answer, showing which of your on-page data points or claims were included.
This is the feedback loop for content teams: Did the AI capture our value proposition correctly? If not, what must we restructure?
Otterly.ai’s lack of this content analysis leaves the GEO team flying blind on one of the most important aspects of optimisation.
3. Daily Audits vs. Bulk Experimentation
- Otterly.ai’s Web Audit: By auditing structured data and content layout, it addresses the technical shortcomings that often prevent citation, even if the content is excellent. This is an essential, immediate-value feature for any SEO team.
- Visble.ai’s Volume Edge: The 50 prompt starting point is non-negotiable for competitive work. A typical brand needs to track ~5 core prompts, ~10 high-intent transactional prompts, and ~5 competitors across those prompts.
Otterly’s 15 prompts force an artificial, non-strategic limitation. This hinders the essential bulk experimentation required. Basically, you don’t get to identify which types of prompts yield the highest citation rate.
Strategic Recommendation
- You’re an enterprise or strategically-driven brand that needs to tie AI visibility directly to specific marketing objectives.
- You prioritise competitive intelligence and narrative control through detailed source and response trend analysis.
- You’re operating with a need for in-depth monitoring and bulk experimentation for optimal value.
Otterly.ai is for you if:
- You’re a small team or solo SEO & GEO, looking for a quick way for technical compliance and basic AI monitoring.
- Your team is highly focused on the technical implementation side and needs the integrated web audit tool to fix on-page readiness issues.
- You’re operating in a market requiring daily reporting for real-time responsiveness.
To Conclude
However, for the SEO team that needs a tool for immediate audit and monitoring the basics, Otterly.ai is an excellent, action-oriented choice.
Ready to boost your AI visibility?
Get your website optimized for AI search engines like ChatGPT, Perplexity, and Gemini.